As a journalist, I’m always looking for the telling anecdote, the short story that sums up in just a few paragraphs the theme of what I’m trying to write about. The story that I think sums up my experience at BEA Bloggers (formerly the Book Blogger Convention) last Monday in New York City is this one:
I was standing in the back of a meeting room during a panel discussion on developing a relationship between bloggers and publishers. As I was in the process of listening to the speakers, taking notes for this post, and following a hashtag discussion on Twitter (#publog), a man walked into the room and start talking to the blogger standing next to me.
In order to make it clear that I was involved with the panel, I pulled my notebook closer to my face, scribbled furiously, and tried to otherwise not make eye contact with him as he stepped over and interrupted what I was doing. After shoving his business card into my hand, he told me he was an author and invited me a signing of this third book the next day. It was all I could do to just tersely say, “Thanks,” and refocus on the panel rather than point out how outrageously rude he had just been. (And that, barring an incident where every book in the world was destroyed except his, I probably wouldn’t be picking up his novel).
I don’t think this particular author intended to be totally inconsiderate. I think we just had different expectations for what was happening in that particular moment and for the entire BEA Blogger experience: I expected to spend the day learning and engaging with other bloggers, while he expected that all bloggers in attendance were there just to “talk with” (i.e. “be pitched too”) by authors and other publishing industry folks.
If it wasn’t already clear, I’ll be blunt — I was disappointed and frustrated by my day spent at BEA Bloggers. It felt like a conference featuring what the publishing industry wants bloggers to be interested in (Authors! Swag! Famous people!), rather than what I think bloggers are actually interested in (connecting with each other in the real world).
This isn’t going to be a post that summarizes the day; I’ll link to a few of those recaps at the end. Instead, I’m going to try to outline my broad concerns with the conference organization and try to offer some suggestions for what I would like to see done differently next year.